Item #25: We've decided that we can each take ONE (1) mulligan a day, and still count it as successful. Today, we made it to about 6:45 pm, when H was recounting a tale, and said "What is this sh*t?" And he immediately tossed out the idea of a mulligan, one per person per day. I think this is within the spirit of the item, so we're good. As long as neither one of us exceeds more than 1. We still need all the luck we can get!
edit: a little before 10 pm, H got frustrated with WoW and said, "Well, sh*t!" and I yelled recriminations at him. Then we both rolled our eyes and said we'd start again, fresh, tomorrow!